Seamless Gutters vs Regular Gutters: Which Is Better For Your Home?

Jun 3, 2023 | Uncategorized

When it comes to gutters, there are two main types: seamless gutters and regular gutters. Both are designed to perform the same function – to collect and direct rainwater away from the home’s foundation. However, they have significant differences that affect their performance and effectiveness.

Seamless gutters, as the name suggests, are made from a single piece of material that is custom-fit to the dimensions of your home. They are created using a roll forming machine that extrudes the gutter material into the desired length, eliminating the need for seams that are present in regular gutters. In contrast, regular gutters are made from pre-cut sections that are assembled and joined together to create the desired length.

One of the primary advantages of seamless gutters is that they are less prone to leaks. Since they are made from a single piece of material, there are no joints or seams that can become damaged or worn over time, causing water to leak out. 

Let’s take a closer look at the battle between seamless gutters vs regular gutters, and find out which gutter system you should choose for your home.

The Different Types Of Regular Gutters

When it comes to regular or “traditional” gutters, there are a few options to choose from based on your material of preference. Each type has its own set of advantages and disadvantages, which can make choosing the right type of gutter system for your home a bit overwhelming.

That’s why we wrote this article! To simplify your understanding and get rid of buying anxiety.

Traditional gutters, also known as sectional gutters, are made up of pre-cut sections that are pieced together (usually in 10 to 20-foot sections) to create the desired length. Each section must be joined together with couplings, and sealed at every joint.

They are typically made from aluminum, copper, vinyl, or galvanized steel and are available in a variety of colors to match the home’s exterior. 

While traditional gutters are typically less expensive than seamless gutters, they are more prone to leaks and are not as durable as seamless gutters.

Vinyl Gutters

Vinyl gutters are an increasingly popular option, particularly for homeowners on a budget, or as a DIY project. They are by far the most economical gutter out there.

However, pricing is about where the pros of vinyl gutters starts and ends in our opinion. 

They are the least durable gutter option on the market and are very prone to cracking in harsh weather conditions like extreme cold. This makes vinyl gutters pretty much a non-starter for homeowners in Alberta. 

Additionally, vinyl gutters are a non-recyclable material that goes straight to landfills. 

Since they don’t hold up against the harsh winters we get here in Edmonton, they are replaced with seamless eaves within a year or two!

Steel Gutters

Without question, steel is the strongest material gutters can be made out of. This makes steel gutters a great choice if you live somewhere with harsh weather conditions because steel gutters can withstand heavy rain, snow, and extreme wind.

The biggest drawback to steel, however, is that it’s the gutter that is the most prone to rust. 

Steel gutters are typically more expensive than other types of gutters and will require more maintenance to prevent rust and corrosion issues.

Aluminum Gutters

Aluminum gutters are a popular choice due to their strength, resistance to rust and corrosion, and the huge range of colors they are available in. 

They are very affordable, and extremely durable if maintained properly, which makes them a common choice for homeowners. Proper maintenance of aluminum gutters can see you getting decades of use out of them.

Copper Gutters

Copper gutters are a high-end option that provides both durability and aesthetic appeal. Like aluminum, copper gutters are also quite strong and do not rust. 

Another consideration with copper gutters is that they can develop a patina over time, giving them a unique and distinctive appearance. This can be either a pro or a con, depending on your taste. After all, they say beauty is in the eye of the beholder!

Like aluminum gutters, proper care and maintenance of copper gutters can be the key to a gutter that lasts for decades. 

Seamless Gutters

Seamless gutters, with Alu-Rex’s T-Rex Continuous Hangar System, have become an increasingly popular choice for homeowners due to their durability, low maintenance, and aesthetic appeal. 

Unlike traditional gutters that are made from pre-cut sections that are joined together during installation, seamless gutters are one solid piece that’s custom-fit to the dimensions of the home. It’s secured evenly along the entire length of your house. This type of gutter completely eliminates the need for seams. 

Features Of Seamless Gutters

The biggest feature of seamless gutters is right in the name. No seams! 

Seams are by far the culprit of most issues with regular gutters, that issue vanishes when you install seamless gutters on your home.

But of course, that’s not all. At Gutter Dunn, we stand behind our aluminum seamless gutters installed with the Alu-Rex T-Rex & Double-Pro, here are some features of these seamless gutters that set them apart from regular gutters:

  • T-Rex supports 105kg/linear foot and the Double-Pro supports 199kg/linear foot. That’s strength regular gutters just can’t compete with!
  • Gutters are installed from end to end with galvanized screws that have a self-sealing rubber gasket. This is what adds to the strength of the gutter and reduces the risk of water infiltration into the fascia.
  • Gutter guards on these products strike the perfect balance between drainage and debris protection. They drain 755mm of water an hour. They also keep snow and ice on top of the product, protecting against expansion due to ice thawing and freezing.
  • 40-year anti-clog warranty & lifetime guarantee on material and sturdiness (T-Rex)
  • Lifetime anti-clog warranty & guarantee on material and sturdiness (Double-Pro)
  • Rollback technology keeps water inside the gutter, even during the heaviest of rainfalls. No overflow.

Installation Of Seamless Gutters Vs Regular Gutters:

The installation process for seamless gutters is typically more involved than that of regular gutters, and is best left to professionals. 

They require a roll forming machine that cuts the material in one piece to the exact measurements of your home. 

Regular gutters on the other hand are typically easier to install since they are made from pre-cut sections that can be “easily” assembled on-site by a capable DIYer, or cheaply from a local contractor. However, where costs are saved on materials and installation, they may be spent in the future on more frequent maintenance or shorter lifespans. 

This is what gives the edge to seamless gutters when it pertains to installation. The materials and cost of labour will be higher, but these gutters will last for decades and require minimal maintenance in comparison to traditional gutters. 

Maintenance And Durability Of Seamless Gutters Vs Regular Gutters

As we’ve said, seamless gutters require very little maintenance. In fact, a soft breeze is often enough to clear away debris from Alu-Rex products! If you do need to take matters into your own hands to clean the gutter, a gutter broom and a light sweep will do the trick.

Because there are no seams, there’s no maintenance to worry about here. The only place seamless gutters even contain any sealant is in the corners. But guess what! The guard on top of the gutter acts as a UV shade, protecting the corner sealant from direct sunlight and eliminating corner leaks!

This is in stark contrast to regular gutters where you need to always be checking the seams and sealant over joints to ensure they aren’t damaged, as this can 100% lead to leaks. 

In terms of debris, a tall broom may not be enough to remove debris that’s accumulated inside of regular gutters. Meaning you may need to get on a ladder and clean out clogs or blockages yourself, or hire a professional to do it. 

Finally, depending on the material of your traditional gutter, you may need to give extra maintenance to avoid rust and corrosion. Alu-Rex seamless gutters are aluminum, so another point for seamless gutters!

There is a pretty clear winner here when it comes to maintenance and durability: Seamless gutters!

Pros And Cons Of Seamless And Regular Gutters

Seamless GuttersRegular Gutters
ProsCustom fit for your homeAffordable & easier to install
Provides a smooth and continuous appearance. Great for curb appeal.Available in a variety of materials & colors
Very low maintenanceCan be installed DIY
Extreme durability – Will last for decades
Leaks and clogs are highly unlikely
ConsMore expensive upfrontProne to leaks and clogs over time
Requires specialized equipment to installJoints and seams can become damaged or worn over time
Requires much more maintenance

Conclusion: Should You Choose Seamless or Regular Gutters For Your Home

When it comes to choosing a gutter system for your home, there is a clear winner that offers many more advantages than its rival, and that’s seamless gutters. 

They have much better durability, require less maintenance, and are less likely to clog. Meaning leaks and all the other damages faulty gutters can cause won’t be keeping you up at night!

However, the cost is definitely a factor for many homeowners. 

Traditional gutters, on the other hand, are more affordable and available in a variety of different materials. They are more prone to leaks and require more maintenance over time.

If you do decide to go with regular gutters for your home, our recommendation is to shop around for aluminum gutters. They are stronger and way more durable than vinyl, and won’t rust or corrode like steel will. 

Ultimately, the decision between seamless and traditional gutters will depend on your specific needs and budget.

Consulting with a professional gutter installer can help determine the best type of gutter system for your home. Regardless of which type of gutter system you choose, maintaining your gutters and keeping them clean is essential for proper function and longevity. 

By choosing the right gutter system and properly maintaining it, you can ensure that your home is protected from water damage and maintains its value for years to come.

Need Eavestrough Services in Edmonton?

Give Us a Call


See why our customers chooses Gutter Dunn!

Cathy PrudenCathy Pruden
01:38 29 Sep 23
Gutter Dunn provided us a reasonable quote for soffits, facia, eavstroughing and gutter guards. We were dealing with improper airflow which was as a result of additional roof venting when a new roof was installed. They were able to open up the older wood soffits before adding new soffits. Employees are friendly and knowledgeable about their product. We are very happy with their work which was done efficiently and in a timely manner and the house looks great! They got the job Dunn! Thanks
Lukas SchillerLukas Schiller
16:49 26 Sep 23
Hands Down, the very best Eavestroughing company in town. They were very professional (from office to the site crew). The workmanship is on point and looks fantastic! I will always recommend this business
Mike RMike R
16:10 11 Sep 23
Took a while to get a quote but well worth the wait. Everyone from the Estimators, Office Staff, Scheduler, and Installers were first class.They explained what was available and what they would recommend. We chose not to go with the leaf protection as we have a 1,200 sq. ft. bungalow and not that much gutter on either our garage or house. It's easy for us to just flush same.FYI their competitors Sales Rep provided a verbal quote and insisted we needed the leave filters and offered at least 5 different discounts and would have charged us double the price that Gutter Dunn invoiced. Competitor would not provide a written quote so I was leary about this company and their Rep.Installers were terrific, showed up a little early and reviewed the scope with us... They also installed new downspouts into our existing storm drain system. What a difference, they inserted the downspout into a pvc fitting vs the old tee pee cone style fitting.They were here for about 3.5 hrs and had everything cleaned up and put away.You know you are dealing with Professionals when they show up in a custom truck with Gutter Dunn and their suppliers ads screened on the side of same. The installers also wore company hats, tees and they were keen to do the work.If I could rate them as a 6 if I could, thanks again Gutter Dunn.
Barbara NBarbara N
21:07 09 Aug 23
They are an absolute delight to work with. I had my old wooden soffit removed and replaced. They were quick to get it done, from the first phone call to them being done was maybe two weeks and it involved coordinating with another contractor to fix the roof. Great communication, called if there was a problem or question, sent easy to understand emails. I can't say enough good things. The work they did was worth every penny.
Ryan McKayRyan McKay
18:15 24 Jul 23
What a great company. They listen to what you want done and then do it. I'll be using them again and now setting up annual gutter clean outs.
Grant Pegden-WrightGrant Pegden-Wright
23:38 21 Jun 23
We had a great experience with Gutter Dunn and our eaves troughs look and perform amazingly well! Would definitely recommend Gutter Dunn to friends and family.
Joel RebohJoel Reboh
15:16 18 Jun 23
Completed my gutters 8 years ago amd they are still in great shape 👍
Eric KEric K
00:27 12 Jun 23
Had soffits/fascia and eavestroughs completed by Gutter Dunn. Both crews were very professional and we are very happy with the final product. The office staff were very helpful as we navigated some other construction delays that affected the scheduling of the Gutter Dunn crews, much appreciated!
Don ShayDon Shay
13:25 07 Jul 21
Professional Service, great advice on product (Soffit, Fascia, 6" Eavestrough & large Downspout Size plus Alu-Rex Double-Pro Leaf Guard). Job was done on time, on quote and they cleaned up so well it was as if they had never been there.
Jean FiliatraultJean Filiatrault
23:10 19 Nov 20
We are very please with the work and workmanship that we received from Gutter Dunn. The eaves that they installed are working very well. the technicians that install the eaves troughs carried their work in a professional manner and were able to answer our questions quickly and to the point. We would certainly recommend Gutter Dunn to friends and family.
Reanna BowdenReanna Bowden
17:25 16 Nov 19
So happy with this Company! They were a little longer getting to me than quoted but worth the wait for the service and attention to detail. They have more selections for qutter profiles than most companies I contacted and they color matched my troughs perfectly to blend in with the exterior. Pricing was also very comparable to other companies when comparing installation techniques. Branden made me an extra extension for my rain barrel in summer, and changed a run on the garage I wanted reversed due to the slope. No hesitation to make it perfect for me. He made sure I loved everything before leaving. My favourite was the duel color downspout to match my exterior. Looks perfect! Thanks for Gutt N’ ER’ Dunn 🙂
Kent LamoureuxKent Lamoureux
18:49 23 Nov 18
I am really happy with how everything went! i picked gutter dunn because of how they came across and the quoting process where they understood what i wanted, so i did not pick them because they were the cheapest but totally competitive in the market and i felt they would get the job done. in the end the design desired was followed and the installer communicated really well to verify. Really happy!